Search 
1-844-PUSHPAY Best church accounting software for parishes and churches
Compare Realm, ParishSOFT, Aplos, and QuickBooks on fund accounting, board-ready reports, and diocesan consolidation for U.S. churches.
Most churches shopping for accounting software think they’re shopping for features. You’re shopping for a reporting audience.
Your finance council needs a statement of activities they can read without a translator. For your auditor, the question is whether restricted fund balances tie out without a spreadsheet sitting in the middle of the trail. And if you’re a Catholic parish, the diocese wants your numbers in their chart of accounts, on their calendar, whether or not that timing works for you.
This is a fund accounting comparison. General ledger, designated funds, chart of accounts, and the statements your board and your auditor read. It’s not a comparison of giving platforms or member databases, even though two of the four vendors below sell those too. That last part turns out to matter more than the feature grid does, and we’ll get to it.
Start with who reads your reports
A few questions decide most of this.
Who signs off on your financials, and what format do they want them in? And how many people need to be in the books at the same time, counting your treasurer and whichever pastor wants read access this year?
Then there’s the one nobody asks until it’s too late. When your treasurer resigns, who’s left who knows how the file is structured?
That last question is incredibly influential. A parish with a volunteer CPA on the finance council can run a complicated system beautifully for six years and then lose all of it in one resignation letter. Church-native software earns its price partly by being learnable by the next person.
The four platforms
| Platform | Fund accounting | Diocesan or multi-entity consolidation | Payroll | Also sells giving & a member database | Published pricing |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ParishStaq® platform from PushpayGiving and donor management | No. Feeds your ledger by fund | Giving and parishioner data, not the ledger | No | Both, in one system | Plans published, quoted pricing |
| Realm (ACS Technologies)Church management with an accounting add-on | Native double-entry ledger by fund and department | Yes, through ACST Catholic | Yes, add-on module | Yes, both | No. Quote only |
| ParishSOFT AccountingParish fund accounting | Native web-based fund ledger | Yes, Consolidation module | Yes, clergy allocations | Yes, through Ministry Brands | No. Quote only |
| AplosNonprofit fund accounting | Native, with statements by fund | No. Single organizations | Through integration | Giving tools, no database | Yes. $79, $129, and up |
| QuickBooks OnlineGeneral business accounting | No. Class tracking workaround | No | Yes, Intuit payroll | No | Yes, published tiers |
- Built in
- Partial or conditional
- Not available
The four accounting platforms are listed below the ParishStaq platform, which is included as the giving and donor management system churches pair with a ledger rather than as a fund accounting product. Figures sourced from vendor sites and product documentation as of September 2026.
Realm from ACS Technologies
Realm fits if your reporting audience is a finance committee that also wants giving and membership data in the same database.
ACS Technologies has been building church software since 1978, and came together with Vanco in December 2025. Realm is their cloud platform. When someone tells you they’re comparing “ACS versus Realm,” they’re comparing two ACS products, usually a legacy desktop system against its replacement.
Accounting attaches as an add-on to any of Realm’s three plans. The module runs on a double-entry general ledger that tracks funds alongside departments and projects, plus a disbursements tool for vendors and check runs. Reporting sits over both.
The real argument for Realm is that contributions post to the ledger without an export step. Your bookkeeper isn’t downloading a CSV every Monday and re-keying deposits. For a 600-attendance church currently running a ChMS and QuickBooks side by side, that one change is usually worth more than any individual report on the feature list.
It only holds if Realm is also where the gift was taken. Run giving anywhere else and you’re importing, same as everyone.
ParishSOFT Accounting
ParishSOFT Accounting fits if your reporting audience is a diocesan finance office with a required chart of accounts.
Ledger and Payables is the web-based core, and Ledger Report Writer builds statements of activity and financial position off your chart of accounts. That second piece is what dioceses actually buy. When the chancery hands down a required format you have to match line for line, a flexible report writer decides whether you comply or build a workaround. Payroll handles clergy allocations, which generic payroll products generally don’t.
Consolidation is the module that puts it on diocesan short lists. It sits above the parish ledgers and gives the diocesan finance office live reporting from every parish and school without anyone collecting anything by email.
Two things to price before you sign. ParishSOFT is a Ministry Brands company, and the accounting module is the front door to a suite that also sells the parish database and giving. Ask what your quote assumes about the rest of it in year two. Then ask who at your parish will be working inside Report Writer after your current business manager leaves, because flexibility and learnability pull against each other.
Aplos
Aplos fits if your reporting audience is a small board and one bookkeeper.
Aplos was started in 2009 by Tim Goetz, a CPA serving as an executive pastor who couldn’t find affordable software for his own church. That origin still shows in the product. Fund accounting is native, restricted funds separate automatically, and a balance sheet by fund comes out without you building anything first.
Lite runs $79 a month and Core $129, with an Advanced tier above that. Annual billing takes 10% off. Your base subscription covers 500 contacts and climbs $20 a month per additional thousand.
Lite and Core include two users, which is where the math usually breaks. Church finance is almost never two people. It’s a bookkeeper and a business manager, plus a treasurer and whichever pastor wants read access this year. Price the seats you actually need before you compare stickers.
QuickBooks
QuickBooks Online fits if your reporting audience is a small board that never asks for a statement of functional expenses.
For years the honest answer to “can we just use QuickBooks?” was yes, with caveats. That answer has changed.
Intuit stopped selling new Desktop subscriptions outside Enterprise in September 2024. That includes Premier Nonprofit, the version a lot of church treasurers have been running since the Obama administration. Support for Desktop 2023 ended May 31, 2026, which took the bank feeds and the payroll tax tables with it, along with any further security patches. Desktop 2024 is the final non-Enterprise release, and its support ends September 30, 2027.
So if your church is on Desktop Premier Nonprofit right now, you have a migration on your calendar whether you’ve scheduled it or not. Enterprise is the only Desktop edition Intuit is still selling and supporting.
Which leaves QuickBooks Online. It’s a competent general business ledger and it does not do fund accounting. You approximate funds by turning on class tracking, creating a class per fund, and tagging every single transaction, forever, without exception. Miss one and your fund report is wrong in a way nobody catches until the audit. Class tracking also requires Plus or Advanced, not the entry tier.
The workaround holds up better than purists admit. Where it breaks is the statement of functional expenses, which QuickBooks can’t generate. You build that in Excel by mapping expense accounts and classes to program, management, and fundraising categories by hand, every year, and it’s one of the most tedious audit prep tasks in the nonprofit world.
What restricted funds cost you at audit time
The technical difference is simple. Under FASB ASU 2016-14 you’re tracking net assets with donor restrictions and net assets without donor restrictions, and the restricted side has to show releases as conditions are met. A native fund ledger enforces that at the transaction level. Class tracking describes it after the fact and trusts you to be consistent.
What you’ll actually feel is the question you didn’t anticipate. Your finance council wants to know how much of the building fund is spendable versus committed to the HVAC contract. In a fund ledger, that’s a report. In a class-based file, that’s an afternoon.
Designated gifts are where this gets messy in real life. A parishioner writes a check for the food pantry with a note on the memo line. That isn’t a donor restriction in the legal sense, it’s a board designation, and the two live in different places on the statement of financial position. Most churches record them identically. Most auditors eventually ask about it.
So which one should you buy?
Small church, under 200, one bookkeeper: Aplos, priced for the seats you actually need. Or QuickBooks Online Plus with disciplined class tracking if your bookkeeper already lives there. Skip the enterprise platforms; you’ll pay for depth you never open.
Catholic parish inside a diocese: call the diocesan finance office before you evaluate anything. Seriously, make that your first call! Many dioceses publish a required chart of accounts and standardize the ledger, and a few have moved to Sage Intacct at the diocesan level. Ask one more question while you have them on the phone. Does the mandate cover the general ledger only, or the parish database too? Those are usually two separate decisions, and parishes lose the second one by assuming it came bundled with the first.
Multi-campus or multi-entity: the test is whether you can produce a consolidated statement without anyone emailing a spreadsheet. A parish ledger with a consolidation layer if you’re a diocese aggregating dozens of entities. Realm with the accounting module if you want people and finances in one vendor’s database and you’re willing to run their giving too. If what you want is people and giving together with the ledger fed from it, that’s a different purchase than an accounting module, and it’s the purchase the ChurchStaq® and ParishStaq platforms answer.
Before your next fiscal year close
A lot of churches close their books June 30, which puts the useful window for this decision in spring, not the week your auditor shows up. Pull your fund list and your last statement of activities, put both in front of whoever signs off on your financials, and ask what they wish the report showed. That conversation narrows this list faster than any demo, and it costs you twenty minutes.
Frequently asked questions
How do ParishSOFT, Aplos, and Realm compare for reporting?
Aplos gives you fund-level statements out of the box with the least setup. Realm’s reporting layer is deeper and connects giving data to the ledger directly, provided the giving runs through Realm. ParishSOFT’s Ledger Report Writer is the most flexible when you have to match a required format line for line. Flexibility costs setup time, so find out who on staff will own it.
Should a Catholic parish use ParishSOFT for accounting?
If your diocese standardizes on it and publishes a required chart of accounts, that decision is largely made for you, and Consolidation is the reason. If your diocese has no standard, or you’re an independent Catholic school, it’s one option among several and worth pricing against Aplos on seat count. Keep the accounting decision separate from the parish database decision either way. The two get quoted together and they don’t have to be bought together.
Does the ParishStaq platform include fund accounting?
No. ParishStaq covers parish giving and the parish database, and the general ledger stays in whatever accounting system your parish or diocese requires. Parishes commonly run it alongside QuickBooks Online or a diocesan ledger.
When does QuickBooks for churches make sense?
When your fund count is low, your bookkeeper already knows QuickBooks, and no external party requires a statement of functional expenses. If you go that route, turn class tracking on and require class coding everywhere QuickBooks allows it. Optional coding produces incomplete fund reports. Your restricted gift policy should also be written down somewhere other than one person’s head.
Does Realm by ACS include accounting plus church management?
Yes, though accounting is a separate add-on module rather than something included in the base plan. You can attach it to Inform, Connect, or Multiply.
Is Aplos good for fund accounting and custom reporting?
Fund accounting, yes. It’s native, not a workaround. Custom reporting and dimensional budgeting by fund, grant, or project sit in the higher tiers, so check which tier your reporting actually requires before you price the entry plan.
Which systems support diocesan consolidation and multi-entity reporting?
ParishSOFT through Consolidation, and ACST Catholic through its diocesan accounting oversight tooling. Some larger dioceses run Sage Intacct instead. Aplos and QuickBooks Online are not built for this.
