Advantages and Disadvantages of 501(c)(3)
Now that we’ve waded through the application process and the requirements to maintain a 501(c)(3) status, it’s time to weigh the pros and cons for your ministry.
Advantages
- Tax exemption reduces operating costs, allowing you to reinvest in ministry.
- Boosts credibility with donors and your congregation.
- Enables charitable organizations to accept tax-deductible contributions.
- Saves on mailing costs, sales tax exemption, and tech discounts (like from Amazon or Microsoft).
- Opens up grant opportunities—such as Google Ad Grants offering $10,000/month for religious nonprofits.
Builds credibility
501(c)(3) status gives donors and supporters increased confidence that the nonprofit organization is reputable and trustworthy- making people more likely to donate to the cause.
Makes contributions tax-deductible
Donors want to give to a religious organization that is trustworthy and doing good work. But it doesn’t hurt when they also get to write off their donations on their taxes.
Brings more saving opportunities
Beyond saving money on income tax, 501(c)(3) churches can save on other expenses, from the US Postal Service and state sales tax to private brands ranging from Amazon to Microsoft.
Unlocks access to grants
As a 501(c)(3) church, you can apply for grants to help your cause. A popular grant for churches to claim is the Google Ad Grants, which offers up to $10,000 each month in ad spend (for free!!) for churches to create highly targeted search ads.
Disadvantages
- The application can cost between $275–$600, with additional fees if using a professional.
- Ongoing paperwork, like the annual Form 990, is still required.
- Exempt organizations must publicly disclose financials, opening the door to scrutiny.
- Stricter IRS regulations around political activity may make church leaders feel limited in what they can say or do.
Application Cost
There is a cost to become a 501(c)(3) church. Expect to pay somewhere between $275-600 to the IRS for the application fee, but you could easily add on $2,000 in fees by having an expert help you organize and file the application.
Piles of paperwork
Unfortunately, being exempt from paying federal income tax doesn’t mean that your church is exempt from filing tax returns. You’ll need to file Form 990 with the IRS annually to report the church’s income. Between the requirement of filing to keep your 501(c)(3) status and the chance of an audit at any time, it’s essential to keep all those documents up to date.
Scrutiny on reports
Once your organization has established that it’s not-for-profit, your financial information becomes public. Anyone can download a copy of your State and Federal filings and see where exactly the money is being spent. While transparency is great at establishing trust with donors, it can also lead to scrutiny if people feel you’re not spending your money as you should.
Fear of violating terms
Churches may end up second-guessing their choices or feeling like they can’t say exactly what they want to out of fear of losing their 501(c)(3) status. With the strict rules in place, especially around politics and activism, a church could risk losing their exemption status.
Manage and track church finances easily
While this post has been written to give you an overview of the process and benefits, we know we’re not the experts in 501(c)(3) exemptions. The IRS and tax pros are. Our specialty is creating tools for the Church, like secure online giving for churches.
We’re here to equip busy church administrators with tools that empower them with donor development, easily integrate with their current systems, streamline donor communication, and simplify reporting to your leaders. Every step of the giving journey is backed by top-notch PCI Level 1 compliance, so you know your donors’ data is safe and secure.
Want to learn more? Schedule a call with one of our product experts!
Sources
https://www.irs.gov/charities-non-profits/churches-integrated-auxiliaries-and-conventions-or-associations-of-churches
https://www.irs.gov/charities-non-profits/churches-religious-organizations
https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/are-churches-always-exempt.html
https://www.financestrategists.com/tax/501c3/501c3-church/