Church ACH giving fees, platform by platform

Compare church ACH giving fees for Pushpay, Tithely, and Subsplash. Explore processing rates and costs to find the best fit for your church.
Jonathan Louvis
Jonathan Louvis November 22, 2026 · 15 min read

The obvious way to compare church ACH giving fees is to check the ACH line on the pricing page, platform by platform. It’s also the least useful comparison you can make.

ACH gifts (electronic transfers from a donor’s checking account, which some platforms call eChecks) cost less to process than card gifts on all three platforms in this comparison. But the lower rate applies only to gifts that arrive by ACH. So when most of your giving comes in on cards, most of your processing bill is card fees.

Your effective rate is the better number to watch. It’s your total processing fees divided by your total giving, and it drops as more donors pick a bank account over a card. Across the industry, about one giving dollar in five arrives by ACH. Pushpay® churches average one in three.

The giving form decides a lot of that. A donor asked to log in to their bank to verify an account has one more step to finish before the gift goes through. A card skips it.

This comparison covers Pushpay Giving, Tithely, and Subsplash. It starts with what ACH costs on each platform and how fast the money reaches your bank account. Then it covers how each verifies a donor’s bank account and the contract terms to check before you switch.

Each platform fits a different ACH priority. Yours might be the lowest flat rate, no subscription or contract, or more of your giving on ACH. Settle that first. It will shape your church ACH giving fees more than the ACH line on the pricing page.

ACH, eCheck, and what the labels mean

An eCheck is an ACH debit. The donor enters a routing number and an account number, and the gift travels the Automated Clearing House network. The Federal Reserve and The Clearing House run that network under Nacha rules. Pricing pages label it differently: Tithely lists “ACH/Bank,” Subsplash lists “ACH (Bank Account),” and the Pushpay giving page lists ACH next to cards and Apple Pay. Same network, three labels.

Where ACH and cards part ways is timing. A card gift is authorized while the donor is still on the giving form, so a declined card fails on the spot. An ACH debit settles afterward. Nacha estimates that about 80% of ACH payments settle in one banking day or less. Your giving platform’s deposit schedule then adds its own time before the money reaches your account. And when an ACH gift fails, for insufficient funds or a closed account, it comes back as a return after the donor has left the form.

So ask every platform for its rates split by card and ACH. A single “online giving” rate hides the number this comparison is about.

Where the money goes on a bank gift

How Pushpay, Tithely, and Subsplash price an ACH gift

The Pushpay platform sets its ACH rate by your church’s total giving volume, from 0.5% to 1.0% plus a flat $0.20 to $0.30 per gift. Subsplash charges 1.00% and no transaction fee on an ACH gift, on its Giving Only, Non-Exclusive, and Exclusive tiers. Tithely charges 1% plus $0.30 per ACH gift on its free giving plan.

ACH gift Pushpay (0.5% to 1.0% + $0.20 to $0.30) Tithely (1% + $0.30) Subsplash (1%)
$50 $0.45 to $0.80 $0.80 $0.50
$250 $1.45 to $2.80 $2.80 $2.50
$1,000 $5.20 to $10.30 $10.30 $10.00

The Pushpay range runs from the lowest ACH price in this comparison to Tithely’s rate, depending on your church’s total giving volume. At the low end, a $1,000 gift costs about half what it costs on Subsplash. Between the two flat rates, Subsplash comes out $0.30 cheaper than Tithely on every ACH gift, whatever the size. The gap shows most on small gifts. At $50, the fixed fee is more than a third of what Tithely charges for the gift. At $1,000, about 3%.

None of the three publishes a cap on ACH fees. A percentage fee grows with the gift, so a $10,000 bank transfer carries between $50 and $100 in fees, depending on the platform and your rate. If large year-end gifts reach your church by bank transfer, ask for an ACH fee cap in writing.

Plan price, add-ons, and the card share

Add the plan’s monthly price and any add-ons to your processing fees, and you have the annual cost of giving on a platform. A $0 subscription moves that whole cost into processing. But processing follows the card share of your giving more than the ACH rate. Take a 2.9% card rate and a 1% ACH rate. If one giving dollar in five arrives by ACH, less than a tenth of the processing bill is ACH fees. The card rate sets that bill.

The mix behind your effective rate

Hold the rates still and move only the mix. At those same rates, with one giving dollar in five arriving by ACH, the effective rate comes to 2.52%. At one in three, 2.27%. So a church at one in three pays about $2.50 less on every $1,000 given, with no change to either rate.

Churches on the Pushpay platform average that one-in-three mix, and their effective rate averages 2.2%. Part of the reason sits on the giving form. On the Pushpay platform, a donor can give by ACH without logging in to their bank. One step fewer.

Shopping for a lower ACH rate while most of your giving runs on cards means negotiating the smallest line on the bill. Move the mix first.

And a bank account doesn’t expire, so a recurring ACH gift keeps running when a donor’s card is replaced.

Pushpay, Tithely, and Subsplash side by side

The figures below come from each company’s website as of November 9, 2026. Confirm each one with the vendor before you sign.

Pushpay Tithely Subsplash
ACH rate 0.5% to 1.0% + $0.20 to $0.30 per gift, set by total giving volume 1% + $0.30 per gift 1.00%, no transaction fee
Card rate (Visa and Mastercard) 2.1% to 2.9% + $0.20 to $0.30 per gift, set by total giving volume 2.9% + $0.30 per gift 2.99% + $0.30, or 2.30% + $0.30 with an Exclusive Partnership
Monthly fee for giving Core, Advanced, and Complete packages, quoted after a demo, with no setup fees; text giving included $0 on Free Online Giving; text giving adds $19 a month $0 for Subsplash Giving; text giving included
Contract 1, 2, or 3 years None Exclusive rates require an Exclusive Partnership agreement
Default deposit schedule Following business day Weekly, every Wednesday; daily on request. ACH gifts can take up to 10 business days to process Weekly, every Wednesday. ACH gifts take three to four business days to process, up to seven during the holiday season
What lands in your bank account The full amount donors gave; processing fees invoiced separately Gifts minus processing fees Gifts minus processing fees

The rate rows draw the most attention, but the deposit rows shape your bookkeeper’s week. On Tithely and Subsplash, fees come out of the gifts before the money moves. Each deposit lands smaller than the giving behind it, and someone records the difference as an expense, deposit by deposit. On the Pushpay platform, the deposit matches the giving, and fees arrive on one invoice.

Deposit timing splits the three platforms the same way. Tithely and Subsplash both default to weekly deposits, every Wednesday, and an ACH gift has to finish processing before it makes a deposit. Tithely offers daily deposits on request and says an ACH gift can take up to 10 business days to process. Subsplash says ACH gifts take three to four business days, and up to seven during the holiday season. Pushpay gifts arrive sooner. They land the following business day.

Which platform fits your ACH priority?

Pushpay

Pushpay Giving fits if your ACH priority is more of your giving on ACH.

Pushpay Giving operates as an ISO (an independent sales organization) in partnership with a payment processor. As an ISO, Pushpay takes on more of the processing risk and compliance responsibility than a platform that plugs into another company’s payment system. The transaction success rate on the Pushpay platform is 95.1%, against an industry standard of 92.5%. Out of every 1,000 attempted gifts, about 26 more go through.

Rates fall as your church’s total giving volume grows, from 2.9% to 2.1% on cards and from 1.0% to 0.5% on ACH, plus $0.20 to $0.30 per gift. A free giving analysis based on your church’s size and setup shows where your church lands. It comes with a package quote in Core, Advanced, or Complete, with no setup fees.

Tithely

Tithely fits if your ACH priority is no subscription or contract. It has neither. Free Online Giving costs $0 a month, and refunds, disputes, and deposits carry no extra charge. You pay 1% plus $0.30 per ACH gift and can leave whenever you want. But that fixed $0.30 lands on every gift, and each deposit arrives net of fees. If most of your ACH gifts are large and your bookkeeper already records fees from each deposit, neither costs you much.

Subsplash

Among flat ACH rates, the lowest in this comparison belongs to Subsplash. One percent, with no per-gift fee, on every tier. Subsplash fits if your ACH priority is the lowest flat rate and giving is one part of an app and website package. Exclusive Partners may also qualify for GrowCurve volume rebates, applied quarterly, which Subsplash says can bring ACH as low as 0.5%. Half the listed rate.

ACH doesn’t reach every payment on Subsplash. Event registrations and payment forms take cards only, at 3.50% plus $0.30, so camp fees and other non-charitable payments can’t move to ACH. Gifts can.

Verifying the bank account behind a gift

Every online ACH gift runs under a fraud rule. Since March 19, 2021, Nacha has required anyone who collects ACH debits online to screen them with a “commercially reasonable fraudulent transaction detection system.” That screening includes validating the bank account the first time it’s used, and again whenever the account number changes.

It’s easy to assume the safest giving form is the one that sends donors to log in to their bank. Nacha doesn’t say so. Its rules are “neutral with regard to specific methods or technologies to validate account information.” Its examples include a prenotification entry (a zero-dollar test sent before the first debit), micro-deposits, and commercial validation services that check the account. Bank login is one method among several.

Each method asks something different of the donor. A bank login confirms the account on the spot, and the donor stops to sign in to their bank to do it. Micro-deposits wait on a few small test amounts to land and get confirmed, so the first gift waits too. A validation service runs in the background after the donor enters a routing number and an account number. No detour.

Validation stops mistyped and nonexistent account numbers. Returns are a separate matter. Most ACH returns, for insufficient funds or a closed account, come back within two banking days of settlement. But a debit the donor says didn’t match what they authorized can come back up to 60 days later. Either way, a gift you already counted comes back out of your records.

So ask every platform three questions about bank gifts:

  • Validation: how it checks a donor’s bank account the first time the account is used
  • Return fees: whether your church or the platform pays the fee on a returned gift
  • Reconciliation: where a returned gift shows up in your reports and your deposits

Before you change providers

A donor’s saved bank account doesn’t move to a new platform, so every recurring ACH giver has to set up the gift again on the one you switch to. Plan that ask first.

On a move to Pushpay, the Recurring Migration tool runs that ask. Your Pushpay specialist customizes pre-built email templates, and donors complete their own move from the email. A real-time dashboard shows who has switched and who hasn’t. Donors who start and don’t finish get automated reminders. Donor records and giving history come over in the data import, with year-to-date totals, recurring schedules, and pledge balances attached to each record.

Monthly digital giving at the Cathedral of Christ the Light in Oakland, California, doubled within two months of its October 2023 switch to Pushpay. The cathedral oversees three parish communities, two of them without offices, and its previous platform was hard for donors to use and harder for staff to manage across locations. “Since we implemented Pushpay, people have said, ‘Wow, this is really easy,'” said Fr. Brandon Macadaeg, the cathedral’s rector from 2019 to 2025. “It’s modern. It’s accessible.”

The books come next. Ask each platform which accounting system it connects to and how gifts post by fund. Pushpay Giving connects to QuickBooks Online, Sage Intacct, Aplos, and Shelby Financials. If your church has more than one campus, decide how gifts will be tagged by campus before the data import, so ACH gifts land in the right place from the first deposit.

And read your current contract before you sign a new one. Its end date and notice terms decide when you stop paying for the old platform.

ACH giving questions from finance teams

What’s the best church giving option for ACH and eCheck processing?

It depends on your ACH priority. For a church that wants more of its giving on ACH, Pushpay Giving is the strongest fit. Donors can give by ACH without logging in to their bank, and Pushpay churches average one giving dollar in three through ACH. The ACH rate falls as low as 0.5% plus $0.20 as total giving grows. Subsplash has the lowest flat ACH rate, at 1%. Tithely charges no monthly fee and asks for no contract.

Can donors cover the processing fee on an ACH gift?

Yes, on all three platforms. On the Pushpay platform, Donor Covers Fees (part of the Everygift® feature set) adds the processing fee to a gift when the donor chooses to. Tithely shows Cover the Fees on the giving form by default. Subsplash preselects the option once an admin turns it on. At a 1% ACH rate, a donor covering the fee on a $100 gift gives $101.01.

Do ACH gifts show up on year-end giving statements?

Yes. A gift from a bank account counts as a contribution the same way a check does. Pushpay giving statements can list cash, check, ACH, and card gifts together. A returned ACH gift never reached the church, so it doesn’t belong on the statement.

Should a large gift come by ACH or by wire transfer?

ACH, unless the money has to arrive the same day. A wire settles the same day if it’s sent before the bank’s cutoff. But it’s final once processed, and it costs more because each wire is handled individually. A wire also goes straight to your bank account, outside your giving platform. So someone on staff records it by hand, while an ACH gift through your giving form lands on the donor’s record automatically.

Jonathan Louvis
Jonathan Louvis Jon is the Administrative Pastor at his local church in Ohio and had the privilege of being a part of the Pushpay team for a number of years. Having worked extensively in both church leadership and church tech, he brings a unique perspective on ministry and the adoption of church technology. When he’s not working, you can find him spending time with his wife, two sons, and dog, or indulging his love of fantasy football. Jon holds a B.S. in Marketing Management and an M.B.A. from Western Governors University. You can connect with him on LinkedIn. View more posts from Jonathan Louvis
Take the next steps for your growing ministry.

Stop managing your people and start inspiring deeper forms of community.

Get Bi-Weekly Updates