Pushpay vs. PayPal for Churches

PayPal’s Online Fundraising and Donation Platform is a tool used by churches to handle the basics of online giving, but lacks the capacity to truly support a church’s need to connect and engage with their congregation.

Join the 14,000 churches that trust Pushpay for all their technology needs.

Everything Pushpay has created over the past decade has been designed for the Church, by people passionate about serving its needs. We’ve never aimed for mass-market adoption; we simply believe that mission-based organizations deserve great software.

That vision has driven our team to develop the industry-leading technology churches depend on to manage their teams, facilitate secure online giving, engage their congregations—and ensure the success of their mission.

If you’re currently using or considering adopting PayPal for your church, let us settle the Pushpay vs PayPal debate with why we are the better option for your giving.

  • Product Features
  • Church AppsChurch Apps
  • Custom branded Church AppCustom branded Church App
  • Container AppContainer App
  • Dynamic HomescreenDynamic Homescreen
  • Rich Push NotificationsRich Push Notifications
  • Suggested ContentSuggested Content
  • Pre-CheckPre-Check
  • Resi Streaming IntegrationResi Streaming Integration
  • Multi-Campus Targeted Push NotificationsMulti-Campus Targeted Push Notifications
  • App Content AnalyticsApp Content Analytics
  • QR Code for App DownloadQR Code for App Download
  • Fill in the blank Sermon NotesFill in the blank Sermon Notes
  • Push Notification Quick PollsPush Notification Quick Polls
  • LEAD App (including the below)LEAD App (including the below)
  • Mobile Access to Member Profiles, Serving History and Church DirectoryMobile Access to Member Profiles, Serving History and Church Directory
  • Volunteer Schedule AccessVolunteer Schedule Access
  • Worship Plan AccessWorship Plan Access
  • Workflows AccessWorkflows Access
  • GivingGiving
  • Simplified GivingSimplified Giving
  • Patented Recurring Gift SuggestionsPatented Recurring Gift Suggestions
  • Customizable Thank You Message By FundCustomizable Thank You Message By Fund
  • Giving Thank You AnimationGiving Thank You Animation
  • Donor InsightsDonor Insights
  • Spanish LanguageSpanish Language
  • In-House Payment Processing ServicesIn-House Payment Processing Services
  • Custom QR Code GeneratorCustom QR Code Generator
  • Email Thank You for Check and Cash GiftsEmail Thank You for Check and Cash Gifts
  • Offline ConversionOffline Conversion
  • Automated Weekly Giving SummariesAutomated Weekly Giving Summaries
  • Recurring Gift Migration ToolRecurring Gift Migration Tool
  • Check Scanning and Image StorageCheck Scanning and Image Storage
  • Church Management SoftwareChurch Management Software
  • Group ManagementGroup Management
  • Service PlanningService Planning
  • Event Check-InEvent Check-In
  • Child Check-InChild Check-In
  • Check-In AnnouncementsCheck-In Announcements
  • Lyric and Chord Chart EditorLyric and Chord Chart Editor
  • Serving RotationsServing Rotations
  • Automatic Scheduled ReportsAutomatic Scheduled Reports
  • Create and Share Custom ReportsCreate and Share Custom Reports
  • Apple PayApple Pay
  • Stock GivingStock Giving
  • CryptocurrencyCryptocurrency
  • Pushpay®
  • Church Apps no
  • Custom branded Church App no
  • Container App no
  • Dynamic Homescreen no
  • Rich Push Notifications no
  • Suggested Content no
  • Pre-Check no
  • Resi Streaming Integration no
  • Multi-Campus Targeted Push Notifications no
  • App Content Analytics no
  • QR Code for App Download no
  • Fill in the blank Sermon Notes no
  • Push Notification Quick Polls no
  • LEAD App (including the below) no
  • Mobile Access to Member Profiles, Serving History and Church Directory no
  • Volunteer Schedule Access no
  • Worship Plan Access no
  • Workflows Access no
  • Giving no
  • Simplified Giving no
  • Patented Recurring Gift Suggestions no
  • Customizable Thank You Message By Fund no
  • Giving Thank You Animation no
  • Donor Insights no
  • Spanish Language no
  • In-House Payment Processing Services no
  • Custom QR Code Generator no
  • Email Thank You for Check and Cash Gifts no
  • Offline Conversion no
  • Automated Weekly Giving Summaries no
  • Recurring Gift Migration Tool no
  • Check Scanning and Image Storage no
  • Church Management Software no
  • Group Management no
  • Service Planning no
  • Event Check-In no
  • Child Check-In no
  • Check-In Announcements no
  • Lyric and Chord Chart Editor no
  • Serving Rotations no
  • Automatic Scheduled Reports no
  • Create and Share Custom Reports no
  • Apple Pay yes
  • Stock Giving yes
  • Cryptocurrency yes
  • Paypal®
  • Church Apps no
  • Custom branded Church App no
  • Container App no
  • Dynamic Homescreen no
  • Rich Push Notifications no
  • Suggested Content no
  • Pre-Check no
  • Resi Streaming Integration no
  • Multi-Campus Targeted Push Notifications no
  • App Content Analytics no
  • QR Code for App Download no
  • Fill in the blank Sermon Notes no
  • Push Notification Quick Polls no
  • LEAD App (including the below) no
  • Mobile Access to Member Profiles, Serving History and Church Directory no
  • Volunteer Schedule Access no
  • Worship Plan Access no
  • Workflows Access no
  • Giving no
  • Simplified Giving no
  • Patented Recurring Gift Suggestions no
  • Customizable Thank You Message By Fund no
  • Giving Thank You Animation no
  • Donor Insights no
  • Spanish Language no
  • In-House Payment Processing Services no
  • Custom QR Code Generator no
  • Email Thank You for Check and Cash Gifts no
  • Offline Conversion no
  • Automated Weekly Giving Summaries no
  • Recurring Gift Migration Tool no
  • Check Scanning and Image Storage no
  • Church Management Software no
  • Group Management no
  • Service Planning no
  • Event Check-In no
  • Child Check-In no
  • Check-In Announcements no
  • Lyric and Chord Chart Editor no
  • Serving Rotations no
  • Automatic Scheduled Reports no
  • Create and Share Custom Reports no
  • Apple Pay yes
  • Stock Giving no
  • Cryptocurrency no

A Better Church Software Experience Awaits.
Register For A Free Demo.

A Tailored Online Giving Tool Proven To Increase Generosity

While PayPal can send and receive payments, it wasn’t designed with the Church in mind, so it lacks the vast array of tools and features Church leaders, staff, and congregations need:

  • Pushpay’s Donor Development Dashboard allows administrators to track individuals’ giving history, forecast recurring gifts and online donations, view new contributions, provide annual giving statements, and review transactions.
  • Our platform empowers your congregants to contribute to a specific fund from their credit card or debit card so that they can give to the projects and ministries they feel most connected with.
  • On average, churches that make full use of Pushpay’s giving solution see a 12% increase in donations and a 24% boost in recurring givers. What’s more, churches using both our ChMS and Giving Solutions see an average increase twenty-one times larger than their subscription cost.

Free Ebook: Church Technology Buyer’s Guide

Fully Customizable Branding On Your Giving App

Instead of a cold and impersonal tool, our customized giving app improves donor management and ensures your Church family feels connected through a digital experience that embraces everything that makes your Church unique:

  • Our simple admin tools let you incorporate your colors, logos, and background imagery to ensure the heart of your church shines through.
  • Pushpay is the only Church giving platform that offers custom Thank You notes, allowing you to tailor your message to which ministry an individual gave to and add a personal note of thanks.
  • Our platform allows you to choose between several animations to acknowledge each gift from your congregants, as yet another (adorable!) way to say thank you.

The Power of Recurring Giving

A strong base of recurring givers helps you more accurately forecast your budget for annual operations and future ministry projects. Instead of hoping your members consistently make donations, Pushpay’s Recurring Giving feature allows regular gifts to be scheduled, which benefits your members and your administrative team:

  • Pushpay makes Recurring Giving incredibly simple. Your members can set up their automatic gift in just moments, taking one more responsibility off their plate.
  • Only Pushpay offers Recurring Suggestions, a feature that uses patent-pending A.I. and Machine Learning technology to gently encourage your congregation toward establishing good giving practices.
  • If you already have recurring givers through a different giving solution, Pushpay’s Recurring Migration tools make transitioning them to our platform as easy and stress-free as possible.
  • Pushpay customers using our online giving platform see a higher share of recurring giving compared to other giving solutions.

Over 80 Powerful Integrations

Pushpay maintains the breadth and depth of features your growing ministry needs. Our seamless integrations with popular church solutions like Checkr, Quickbooks, Mailchimp, Resi, PCO, Rock RMS and more have been proven to decrease administrative workload by as much as 65%.

Award-Winning Support

Our team is committed to serving your church and your congregation. That’s why we’ve invested the time and resources necessary to ensure you always have the support you need:

  • An all-in-one Customer Portal that hosts hundreds of support articles for all our products, as well as several smart features to help you find the answers you need quickly.
  • Pushpay University is an on-demand learning platform that equips Church leaders to overcome current and future challenges their organizations may face, bolstered by insights from experts around the world.
  • Our award-winning support team is available 24/7 for any situation that arises.

Like What You See? Register To Talk To A Church Tech Expert.

Explore Additional Comparison Guides

Curious how Pushpay stacks against other church management software and donation platforms? Check out our comparison guides for more information.

Pushpay vs PayPal

Pushpay vs Breeze

Pushpay vs Realm

Testimonials

Tiffany Meaney
Bellevue Presbyterian Church
"We recently launched a one-time giving campaign to raise funds for refugees forced from their homes in the Congo due to violence in that area. Our goal was $30k, we raised over $400k! This never could have happened without Pushpay!"
Jennifer Ford
Hosanna! Church
"Our whole experience with Pushpay has required such minimal effort on our part. That translated into such a great giving experience on Easter and helped us raise more than $200,000 for four great organizations."
Sarah Jones
First Baptist Church of Reeltown
"Pushpay has been the single greatest avenue of connection between the congregation and the church as a whole. To say that we’ve been blessed through your company is an understatement."

Help us make this page great! If you see something that is inaccurate or misrepresented, or have an idea to improve it, please contact us.